Skip to content
Largest Business

Largest Business

Iphone Business

Primary Menu
  • Business Support
  • Business News
  • Largest Business
  • Dell Business
  • Business Cnn
  • Financial
  • About Us
    • Advertise Here
    • Contact Us
    • Privacy Policy
    • Sitemap
  • Home
  • Property owners and officials find ways around century-old laws as the West runs out of water
  • Business Cnn

Property owners and officials find ways around century-old laws as the West runs out of water

By Talia Koe 11 months ago

By Stephanie Elam, CNN

With a megadrought draining water reserves in the West, states are looking for alternatives to handle water rights, many of which were set more than 100 years ago when water supplies were far more abundant.

Back then, just posting a sign next to a water diversion was enough to be considered a right, one which could still be honored now. But the climate crisis is now straining those rights. There just isn’t enough water in California to satisfy what’s been allotted on paper.

For years, debate has raged in California about the best way to fix the water rights system for life in the modern era. Many of the senior water rights held in the state were set before 1914 when the permit system was established and when mining was big business.

“It’s an old water system that many perceive isn’t set up to deal with current climatic and hydraulic conditions,” Nathan Metcalf, a water rights attorney for California law firm Hanson Bridgett, told CNN. “It’s just not really set up to deal with climate change and the changing needs for water both from an environmental standpoint, and then there’s also the rub between agriculture and municipal.”

Recognizing the dour effect of climate change on the state’s hydrology, Democrats in California’s Senate have proposed using $7.5 billion in state and federal funds to “build a climate-resilient water system.”

Of those funds, $1.5 billion would be used to buy land with senior water rights from holders willing to sell them voluntarily in prioritized waters. The Democrats argue “fundamental changes” to the state’s water system are “needed to realign demand, supply, and the flexibility of the system.”

The proposal, which has yet to work its way through the legislature, would look to “retire water use incrementally from multiple water uses in a basin and across wide geographies” which would help provide clean drinking water while also improving fish habitats and wildlife refuge conditions.

“The problem with trying to regulate the senior water rights is that it’s a property interest, so you always run the risk of a takings claim by taking that property,” Metcalf said.

A takings claim could be brought by property owners against the government if it seizes private property for public use. Owners could also make a takings claim if regulations go too far in restricting their use of the land.

But Metcalf said there could be situations where it’s mutually beneficial for a property owner to cede his or her water rights.

“If it’s economically advantageous for both the farmer and the state to purchase those water rights to put to another use, I think that’s a possibility,” Metcalf said. “I could also see certain agricultural sectors being opposed to that because you never know when or how you’re going to use that water right in the future.”

Metcalf said the government could simply buy senior water rights, which might be an easier option than trying to regulate those rights, which often leads to years of litigation.

A novel approach

In Northern California, the State Water Board is trying something it has never tried before: a voluntary water sharing agreement for water rights holders in the Upper Russian River watershed in Mendocino and Sonoma Counties.

For months, rights holders met once a week to come up with an agreement in anticipation of another supply shortage. It’s an effort to avoid curtailments spurred by the severe drought conditions last year, which led to water demand outstripping supply.

“Conditions deteriorated so quickly, there weren’t really alternative options. We had to move forward with the curtailment process. We developed an emergency regulation,” said Sam Boland-Brien, a supervising engineer with the State Water Board. “That resulted in all kinds of surface water users … in the upper part of this watershed having to stop diversions.”

In fact, water levels got so low, “there was this really concrete risk that Lake Mendocino up near Ukiah was going to run empty,” Boland-Brien said, adding the storms rolling through in October last year kept the lake from running dry before the end of winter.

Coming too close to running out of water was the catalyst to find a better way to share water, he said.

The State Water Board said more than half of the total eligible water rights holders have signed up for the program, including municipalities along the river which hold the oldest rights in the watershed dating back to the late 1800s as well as local water districts and some larger institutional wineries.

The more rights holders involved, the better. By enrolling in the program, rights holders committed to a water use reduction of up to 20% to 30% for senior holders. Due to the oppressive drought, cities are also enforcing water conservation. Those water savings are incorporated into what can be shared with other rights holders in the community as well, Boland-Brien noted.

All the agreements create a pool of water available for more junior rights holders who would have otherwise had their water curtailed. Participants can also do further transfers or exchanges among each other, creating an added level of flexibility.

“What the program achieves is, it smooths out that ‘all or nothing’ aspect of the appropriative system,” Boland-Brien explained. He said a better-managed, voluntary system is more likely to get buy-in from rights holders than state regulatory actions alone.

“Those who still have water rights, produce a little bit,” Boland-Brien said. “They reduced their usage … so those that [have more junior rights] can make it through the irrigation season on a reduced amount.”

An emergency curtailment regulation remains in place as a backstop for those rights holders who did not join in the program. As water levels continue to drop, curtailments will kick in based on seniority.

The program went into effect July 1 and will expire at the end of the year, but there’s hope that it could be expanded into the future.

“The idea is that this would continue in future years and so each year there would be a slightly different mix of water supplies and people signed up so that even if you’re a junior some years, you could still benefit from the flexibility,” Boland-Brien said.

A court rules in favor of deviating from the law

The Upper Russian River program is in line with what Mike Young, a professor at the University of Adelaide and a specialist in water policy reform, says is needed to equitably handle water rights in drought-stricken areas, except, he argues, every rights holder needs to be included in any water-sharing program.

“Everybody has a percentage share of whatever is available and that goes up and down,” Young said to CNN. “Have boards that make decisions in the interest of everybody, and everybody has an incentive to make the system work. The board makes the final decision, and the profits are allocated to shareholders … You run a water accounting system that looks like your bank account.”

In Nevada, a fight over Diamond Valley’s groundwater rights ended up at the Nevada Supreme Court, which set a precedent when it ruled 4-3 the state engineer can deviate from Nevada’s water laws, which are based on water rights seniority, to regulate Diamond Valley’s water under a new groundwater management plan approved by those water users when supplies are depleting.

About four years ago, Young spent time with farmers in Diamond Valley, an area in Eureka County which relies heavily on groundwater; too heavily, Young said. According to the court’s ruling, “the Diamond Valley Hydrologic Basin is over-appropriated and over-pumped, such that groundwater withdrawals from the Basin exceed its perennial yield.”

“The thing about rivers and groundwater resources is they don’t lie,” Young said, adding in one day, he helped the farmers draft the new groundwater management plan.

“Someone’s got to write the rule book down and the problem is that America doesn’t have a decent rulebook for playing the game called water use,” Young said. He argues developing water accounting systems where the resource is scarce should be basic.

“Every irrigator in the west should have a water account that says how much water they may take from the system,” Young said. “Taking water that is not in your account is seen by everyone as bad as going next door and harvesting their crop.”

The-CNN-Wire
™ & © 2022 Cable News Network, Inc., a WarnerMedia Company. All rights reserved.

Tags: Amazon Business Login, Amazon Business Prime, Bank Of America Business Account, Best Business Schools, Business Attorney Near Me, Business Bank Account, Business Card Holder, Business Card Maker, Business Card Template, Business Cards Near Me, Business Casual Attire, Business Casual Shoes, Business Casual Woman, Business Plan Examples, Ca Business Search, Ca Sos Business Search, Capital One Business Credit Card, Chase Business Checking, Chase Business Credit Cards, Chase Business Customer Service, Chase Business Login, Chase Business Phone Number, Cheap Business Cards, Citizens Business Bank, Cox Business Login, Digital Business Card, Facebook Business Suite, Finance In Business, Free Business Cards, Google Business Login, Harvard Business School, Lands End Business, Massage Parlor Business Near Me, Michigan Business Entity Search, Mind Your Business, Mind Your Own Business, Ohio Business Search, Risky Business Costume, Skype For Business, Small Business Loan, Small Business Saturday 2021, Starting A Business, Texas Business Entity Search, Triumph Business Capital, Vending Machine Business, Verizon Business Customer Service, Vonage Business Login, Wells Fargo Business Account, Yahoo Small Business, Yahoo Small Business Login

Continue Reading

Previous Summer transfer window: Man City, Liverpool among early winners
Next Twitter says ‘uncertainty’ with Elon Musk is hurting its business
June 2023
M T W T F S S
 1234
567891011
12131415161718
19202122232425
2627282930  
« May    

Archives

  • June 2023
  • May 2023
  • April 2023
  • March 2023
  • February 2023
  • January 2023
  • December 2022
  • November 2022
  • October 2022
  • September 2022
  • August 2022
  • July 2022
  • June 2022
  • May 2022
  • April 2022
  • March 2022
  • February 2022
  • January 2022
  • December 2021
  • November 2021
  • October 2021
  • September 2021
  • August 2021
  • July 2021
  • June 2021
  • May 2021
  • April 2021
  • March 2021
  • February 2021
  • January 2021
  • December 2020
  • November 2020
  • November 2018
  • December 2016

Recent Posts

  • 5 Project Management Essentials That You Need to Know
  • United States Business News
  • How to Use Demo Videos in Your Technical Sales Cycle
  • College endowments are experiencing some whiplash : NPR
  • What Is a Buyer Persona (And Do You Really Need One)?
Intellifluence Trusted Blogger

buildinglink.buybacklinks.online/agence-seo

BL

Tags

5e Business Profit Ahron Levy Columbia Business School Att Business Login Business Business Consultant Certification Austin Business Insurance Cover Coronavirus Business Letter With Logo Example Business Located Easy Location Business Platform Stocks Business Positions Seattle Business Regulation Legal Services Daystarr For Business Dimagi Business Development Toolkit Do Business Schools Accept Entreprenuers Enironmentall Friendly Business Ideas Eric Early Republican Business Owner Essec Business School Dean Essential Business To Remain Open Example Small Business Fall Winter Business Hours Template Fdot Woman Owned Business Certification First Business Women United States First Com Business Fixing A Damaged Reputation Business Florida Business Enforcement Free Small Business Communication Tool Law School Business Entity Outlines Mapping A Business Location Medical Business Trends Economics Mix Business And Personal Money Mlm Nit Small Business Legally New Business Agency Sales Questions Patricia Saiki Women'S Business 1990 Safety Business Proposal Sample Business Plan Entrepreneur School Business Administration Positions S Corp Business Deductions Search Tx Business Llc Sentextsolutions Business Cards Signs For Business On Roads Skype For Business Recording Capacity Small Small Business Forums .Net Small Business Insurancr Tech Monkey Business

Visit Now

Mental Health Test

scorpion pest control in las vegas 

getlinko

kenhphanphoiduanchungcu.xyz | Magazine 7 by AF themes.

WhatsApp us